CasablancaForum.us

Franklin,
That was always my concern as well. But I have several colleagues that switched from the cassie to either FC and Adobe. They all figured it out. I don't know what kind of support you have if you decide to switch, but if I switch, I have plenty of support.
I hope Seth can call me.

Thans Jeff for your fast respond, feel free to e-mail
me for any comments !

I agree with Seth the more tools in your box the better !
I myself want to learn parts of FCP & After Effects to complement my S-4100's
2 weeks ago I had a industry colleague who uses FCP look at our system.
He WAS amazed by the simplicity & the ability to edit very fast
BUT when you want to take your game to the next level our machines are very limited.

So here is to learning other platforms & using ours to create even better productions !

I also have shown serious FCP users the Cassies. All are very impressed with the ease of use and shallow learning curve. When you get down to the brass tacks......Cutting video is cutting video. Lets take Premiere Pro for instance. Adobe offers many "tools" to get the job done. If you are cutting video you would use PP, if you need to create still graphics you would use PS, is you need motion graphics you will use AE and so on and so on. The titler in FCP SUCKS! That is why they created Live Type.

Each app was designed to really excel in a specific arena. If you ask Adobe users....they do not use one app for everything. Just like we don't. I would not use Avid Media Composer to edit audio, I would use Avid Pro Tools. I hope everyone can see where I am going with this.

There is not a "one size fits all" piece of software! Take time to look at how many video players/converters that we all probably have installed on our PC or Mac.

Syl and others are correct in that.....in some cases the cassie is "behind" the competition. BUT....step back and watch....how much more efficient our work flow is compared to the competitions!

I guess we could all talk about this forever. And these are just my opinions.

I still use my Reno+ for the occasional edit, but I have to say I prefer my Adobe CS5 suite. I can have Premiere, Photoshop Extended and After affects all open at the same time and just use whats call the "dynamic link" to jump between programs. It is more complex but once you get the hang of it, the work flow is much better IMO.

If you migrate to a non cassie NLE I'd highly recommend getting a subscription to http://www.lynda.com Its the best 250 bucks a year you'll spend for training (other than the March Get Together of course!) You can learn a program from start to finish, or just do a quick search on a particular effect or technique. I use it almost every day and it has made the learning curve much shorter.

Yep "round tripping" is the only way to go. Lynda is great! I have been a member for years.

Chris,
When did you make the switch? What was your reasoning?

While I want to remain hopeful Joel, I just spoke with Seth and he said unlike Adobe and FC, MS does not have the money to give us the support we expect.